Keep your old phone until you have confirmed your most important sign-ins on the new one. Google Authenticator can sync codes through your Google Account or transfer them with a QR code. The right method depends on whether the codes on the old phone were synced.
Check whether your codes are synced
Open Authenticator on the old phone and check which Google Account, if any, it is using. If the codes are synced, install the app on the new phone and sign into that same account in Authenticator. Check that the expected entries appear. Make sure you can access the Google Account independently if its second factor is on the old phone.
Use a direct transfer for local codes
On the old phone, open Authenticator and look for Transfer accounts → Export accounts. Unlock the device, select the accounts and show the QR code. On the new phone, choose Transfer accounts → Import accounts and scan it. More than one QR code may be needed. Follow Google’s Authenticator transfer guide for your platform.
Do the transfer privately. The QR code contains the information needed to generate the selected codes. Don’t screenshot it, email it or share it with someone offering technical support.
Test the new phone before wiping the old one
Check the entries and verify sign-in for essential accounts such as email and your password manager. Keep an existing signed-in session or backup method while testing. Don’t delete synced entries on the old phone to tidy it up: deleting a synced code can remove it from other devices too.
If the old phone is gone and the codes weren’t synced, use each service’s backup codes or official recovery route. You may need to enrol a new authenticator separately for each account.